A hands-on Vistaprint alternative

Sticker Supply Co vs Vistaprint

Vistaprint, a Cimpress company, sells almost every printed product online, with a self-service design studio, templates, and no-minimum ordering. Sticker Supply Co is a small print shop in South Portland, Maine for stickers, labels, yard signs, and canvas prints, where a designer prepares your proof and you can pick the order up yourself.

Independently researched · Last reviewed November 11, 2026

The honest take

Vistaprint is hard to beat for range and hours: yard signs in many sizes and shapes, templates for nearly anything, and phone support around the clock on most weekdays. Choose Sticker Supply Co when you want a person to check your file before it prints, double-sided yard signs with the stake already included, or free pickup in Greater Portland.

Feature by feature

How Sticker Supply Co and Vistaprint compare

The right choice depends on the job. Here is the practical difference across the factors that usually matter most.

Who makes it

Depends on the job
Sticker Supply Co
A small print team in South Portland, Maine
Vistaprint
A large online printer, part of Cimpress

File check before printing

Sticker Supply edge
Sticker Supply Co
A designer prepares the proof for stickers, labels, and yard signs; you approve it first
Vistaprint
A digital proof you review or set to auto-approve; its terms say uploaded content is not proofed

Yard sign sizes and shapes

Competitor edge
Sticker Supply Co
One size: 24" × 18" rectangle
Vistaprint
Many sizes up to 48" × 96", plus circle, arrow, and house shapes

Yard sign extras

Sticker Supply edge
Sticker Supply Co
Double-sided printing and a metal H-stake included
Vistaprint
Double-sided printing costs extra; stands are added at checkout

Canvas prints

Depends on the job
Sticker Supply Co
Thin flat canvas or 0.75" gallery wrap, 8×10 to 18×24, optional wood frames and watercolor styling
Vistaprint
Seven sizes up to 24×36, 0.75" or 1.5" depth, optional display frames

Getting your order

Sticker Supply edge
Sticker Supply Co
Free local pickup in South Portland, Maine, or shipping anywhere in the US
Vistaprint
Shipped, or sent to a carrier pickup point where available

Support

Strong on both
Sticker Supply Co
Call or email the team making your order, weekdays 8:30–5 ET
Vistaprint
Phone support around the clock Tuesday–Friday, plus chat and email

Guarantee

Competitor edge
Sticker Supply Co
Report defects or our mistakes within 7 days for a reprint or refund
Vistaprint
Report a problem within 14 days of delivery for a refund or free reorder

Give credit where it is due

What Vistaprint does well

A useful comparison should make the competitor's case too. These are meaningful strengths—not straw men.

  • A very large catalog, from business cards to signs, stickers, labels, and canvas
  • Yard signs in many sizes and shapes, with no minimum order
  • A self-service design studio with templates and a free PDF proof download
  • Phone support 24 hours a day Tuesday through Friday, plus evenings and weekends

A person checks your file

Vistaprint shows you a digital proof (or auto-approves it if you choose), but its terms say it does not proof the content customers upload, so proofreading is up to you. Our designers prepare the proof for stickers, labels, and yard signs, and nothing prints until you approve it.

Both sides and the stake included

Every yard sign is printed on both sides of 4mm corrugated plastic and comes with a metal H-stake. There are no add-ons to remember at checkout.

Pick it up in South Portland

Choose free local pickup at checkout and collect your order at our shop near the Maine Mall, or have it shipped anywhere in the US.

Specialty sticker work

Named premium vinyl, white ink, embossing, UV and eco-solvent printing, and one-off projects that do not fit a standard product menu.

Match the printer to the project

Three questions that make the choice easier

1

Do you need an unusual yard sign size or shape?

Vistaprint is the better fit; it offers many sizes and shapes. Our yard signs come in one size, 24" × 18".

2

Do you want someone to catch problems in your file?

Choose Sticker Supply Co. A designer prepares your proof before printing. Vistaprint gives you a digital proof to review yourself, and its terms say it does not proof uploaded content.

3

Are you in or near Portland, Maine?

Choose Sticker Supply Co for free pickup at our South Portland shop and a team you can call or visit.

South Portland, Maine

What every order gets from us

These are not premium support tiers. They are how our small team handles everyday work.

Designer-prepared proof on stickers, labels, and yard signs
Free local pickup in South Portland, Maine
Direct access to a real person on our team
Internal quality checks before the order ships
Double-sided yard signs with the stake included
Defects and our mistakes reprinted or refunded

Questions, answered

Sticker Supply Co vs Vistaprint FAQ

Is Sticker Supply Co a good alternative to Vistaprint for yard signs?+

Yes, for standard 24" × 18" signs. Ours are printed on both sides of 4mm corrugated plastic with a metal H-stake included, a designer prepares the proof, and you can pick them up free in South Portland, Maine. For other sizes or shapes, Vistaprint has more choice.

Does Vistaprint check my artwork before printing?+

Vistaprint gives you a digital proof to review, which you can also set to auto-approve. Its terms say it does not proof content you upload or create, so you are responsible for proofreading. Sticker Supply Co has a designer prepare the proof for stickers, labels, and yard signs.

Are stakes included with Vistaprint yard signs?+

Vistaprint says stands are not included and can be added at checkout. Sticker Supply Co includes a metal H-stake with every yard sign.

Can I pick up my order locally?+

Sticker Supply Co offers free local pickup at 125 John Roberts Road, Suite 11, South Portland, Maine. Vistaprint ships orders, with carrier pickup points available for some products and addresses.

Research notes and sources

Competitor information was checked against the public pages below on November 11, 2026. Products, prices, policies, and turnaround can change, so confirm time-sensitive details before ordering.

Vistaprint is a trademark of its respective owner. Sticker Supply Co is not affiliated with or endorsed by Vistaprint. This page is an informational comparison based on publicly available information and our own service practices.

Still deciding? Send us the real job.

Tell us the surface, quantity, deadline, and what matters most. We will recommend the material and process we would use—before you commit.