Business model
Depends on the job- Sticker Supply Co
- Independent Maine sticker, label, design, and specialty print team
- UPrinting
- Large online commercial printer with a wide catalog
A more personal UPrinting alternative
Sticker Supply Co vs UPrinting
UPrinting is a large online commercial printer with an extensive catalog, multiple sticker formats, digital and hard-copy proof options, and fast production choices. Sticker Supply Co focuses on a more personal print partnership: local designers prepare the files, the Maine production team answers the phone, and unusual jobs are welcome.
Independently researched · Last reviewed September 3, 2026
The honest take
UPrinting is compelling when one vendor and a very broad commercial-print catalog are the priority. Sticker Supply Co is the better fit when you want the sticker or label specialist who will help select, measure, test, proof, and stand behind the exact job.
Feature by feature
How Sticker Supply Co and UPrinting compare
The right choice depends on the job. Here is the practical difference across the factors that usually matter most.
Proofing approach
Depends on the job- Sticker Supply Co
- Local professional designer prepares every customer proof
- UPrinting
- Free digital proof option; paid hard-copy proof available for some work
Sticker materials
Depends on the job- Sticker Supply Co
- Premium vinyl with specific General Formulations high-tack options
- UPrinting
- Paper, BOPP, and vinyl options with several finishes
Production speed
Strong on both- Sticker Supply Co
- Rush orders handled directly with the production team
- UPrinting
- Eligible sticker products advertise one-, two-, or three-day printing
Sampling
Sticker Supply edge- Sticker Supply Co
- Free material samples and free custom test samples on request
- UPrinting
- Free general sample kit; custom sticker samples are not offered for some products
Packaging fit
Sticker Supply edge- Sticker Supply Co
- Packaging-type finder plus hands-on measurement from a mailed or walk-in sample
- UPrinting
- Online sizing guidance and templates
Quality accountability
Sticker Supply edge- Sticker Supply Co
- Individual internal checks, free extras, and a reprint-or-refund guarantee
- UPrinting
- Prepress review and customer service process
Give credit where it is due
What UPrinting does well
A useful comparison should make the competitor's case too. These are meaningful strengths—not straw men.
- Large commercial printing catalog beyond stickers and labels
- Digital proof approval and optional hard-copy color proofs
- Sticker formats including singles, rolls, and sheets
- Published production options beginning at one business day for eligible products
A specialist, not a print marketplace
Stickers, labels, decals, packaging, and the applications around them are everyday work for our team. You can talk through the job with someone who understands how it will be produced.
Designer-led proofing
Every proof and print file is prepared locally by a professional designer before it reaches the customer, with production details resolved up front.
Fit help for real packaging
Bring in or mail us a bottle, jar, pouch, tube, or other container. We will measure it and help determine a label size that fits before you order.
Flexible finishing and print methods
Our team works with both eco-solvent and UV printing and can help with white ink layers, embossing, high-tack vinyl, and other less-standard requests.
Match the printer to the project
Three questions that make the choice easier
Do you need one vendor for many standard marketing products?
UPrinting has the broader conventional commercial-print catalog and may be a practical consolidation choice.
Is the label fit, adhesive, or application uncertain?
Sticker Supply Co is the better fit. We can inspect or measure the packaging, recommend material, and produce a free custom test sample on request.
Do you want a hard-copy color proof?
UPrinting publicly offers a paid hard-copy proof on eligible work. Sticker Supply Co instead offers free material and custom test samples when requested, which can help test the real application.
South Portland, Maine
What every order gets from us
These are not premium support tiers. They are how our small team handles everyday work.
Proof prepared by a professional local designer
Internal quality checks before the order ships
Free extra stickers included in typical runs
Direct access to a real person on our team
Reprint-or-refund full guarantee
High-end Roland printers and Roland-brand inks
Questions, answered
Sticker Supply Co vs UPrinting FAQ
How is Sticker Supply Co different from UPrinting?+
UPrinting is a broad online commercial printer. Sticker Supply Co is a small Maine print team centered on stickers, labels, decals, packaging applications, design support, and specialty projects, with direct access to the people preparing and producing the order.
Does UPrinting offer proofs?+
Yes. UPrinting offers a free digital proof option and advertises paid hard-copy proofs for eligible color-critical work. Sticker Supply Co has a professional local graphic designer prepare every proof before the customer sees it.
Which company is better for packaging labels?+
Sticker Supply Co is especially useful when you are unsure of size, material, or fit. Its labels-by-packaging-type navigation, hands-on measuring service, and custom test samples are designed around real containers and applications.
Can Sticker Supply Co handle rush orders?+
Yes. Rush work is available, and customers can speak directly with the team about the actual deadline, proof timing, production method, and pickup or shipping options.
Research notes and sources
Competitor information was checked against the public pages below on September 3, 2026. Products, prices, policies, and turnaround can change, so confirm time-sensitive details before ordering.
- UPrinting — Custom sticker printing
- UPrinting — Sticker sheets and proofing
- UPrinting — Promotional sticker samples
UPrinting is a trademark of its respective owner. Sticker Supply Co is not affiliated with or endorsed by UPrinting. This page is an informational comparison based on publicly available information and our own service practices.
Still deciding? Send us the real job.
Tell us the surface, quantity, deadline, and what matters most. We will recommend the material and process we would use—before you commit.