A local alternative to Shutterfly canvas

Sticker Supply Co vs Shutterfly canvas prints

Shutterfly is a national photo company with a wide canvas line: sizes up to 36" × 36", a deep 1.5" gallery wrap, floating frames, and multi-panel arrangements. Sticker Supply Co is a small print shop in South Portland, Maine whose photo canvases come thin or gallery-wrapped, with optional watercolor styling and free local pickup.

Independently researched · Last reviewed November 11, 2026

The honest take

Shutterfly offers far more canvas choice: larger sizes, a deeper wrap, seven frame finishes, and multi-panel sets. Choose Sticker Supply Co for a single photo on canvas, an optional watercolor version, approving the exact image that prints, and free pickup in Greater Portland.

Feature by feature

How Sticker Supply Co and Shutterfly compare

The right choice depends on the job. Here is the practical difference across the factors that usually matter most.

Size range

Competitor edge
Sticker Supply Co
8×10 to 18×24
Shutterfly
8×10 to 36×36, including wide sizes such as 12×36

Depth and build

Depends on the job
Sticker Supply Co
Thin (about 0.25", ships flat) or 0.75" gallery wrap on wooden stretcher bars
Shutterfly
1.5" deep (1.25" on 30×40 and 36×36), stretched across solid wood

Frames

Competitor edge
Sticker Supply Co
Black, brown, natural, or white wood frames on standard canvases
Shutterfly
Floating frames in black, white, natural, walnut, rustic, metallic, and matte gold

Multi-panel sets

Competitor edge
Sticker Supply Co
Single-photo canvases
Shutterfly
Multi-panel canvas arrangements

Styling

Sticker Supply edge
Sticker Supply Co
Print the photo as-is, or add optional watercolor styling
Shutterfly
Your photo as uploaded and designed online

Getting your canvas

Sticker Supply edge
Sticker Supply Co
Free local pickup in South Portland, Maine, or shipping anywhere in the US
Shutterfly
Shipped; same-day CVS and Walgreens pickup covers photo prints (4×6 to 16×20)

Where it is made

Depends on the job
Sticker Supply Co
Ordered from a small print shop in South Portland, Maine
Shutterfly
Printed in the USA with globally sourced components

Guarantee

Competitor edge
Sticker Supply Co
Email us within 14 days of delivery; handled case by case
Shutterfly
100% Happiness Guarantee on every product

Give credit where it is due

What Shutterfly does well

A useful comparison should make the competitor's case too. These are meaningful strengths—not straw men.

  • Canvas sizes from 8" × 10" up to 36" × 36", including wide formats such as 12" × 36"
  • A 1.5" deep canvas professionally stretched across solid wood
  • Floating frames in seven finishes, and multi-panel canvas arrangements
  • Every canvas ships with a metal sawtooth hanger

Approve the exact image that prints

You see the final print image before you add the canvas to your cart. The preview you approve is the file we print.

Optional watercolor styling

Keep your photo as it is, or turn on watercolor styling for a painted look and regenerate it until you like the result.

A thin canvas to frame yourself

Thin canvases, about 0.25" with no stretcher bars, ship flat and cost less, so you can frame them your own way.

Pick up in South Portland

Choose free local pickup at checkout and collect your canvas at our shop near the Maine Mall, or have it shipped anywhere in the US.

Match the printer to the project

Three questions that make the choice easier

1

Do you want a large canvas or a multi-panel wall?

Shutterfly is the better fit, with sizes up to 36" × 36", wide formats, and multi-panel arrangements.

2

Would you like a watercolor version of your photo?

Choose Sticker Supply Co. Turn on watercolor styling, preview the result, and approve the exact image before it prints.

3

Are you in or near Portland, Maine?

Choose Sticker Supply Co for free pickup at our South Portland shop and a small team you can call.

South Portland, Maine

What every order gets from us

These are not premium support tiers. They are how our small team handles everyday work.

You approve the exact image that prints
Optional watercolor styling
Ships in 3–4 business days
Free local pickup in South Portland, Maine
Real wood frames, mounted by hand
Direct access to a real person on our team

Questions, answered

Sticker Supply Co vs Shutterfly FAQ

Is Sticker Supply Co a good alternative to Shutterfly for canvas prints?+

Yes, for single-photo canvases up to 18" × 24". You approve the exact image that prints, can add watercolor styling or a real wood frame, and can pick the canvas up free in South Portland, Maine. For larger sizes, deeper wraps, or multi-panel sets, Shutterfly has more options.

What is the difference between a thin and a gallery-wrapped canvas?+

Our thin canvases are about 0.25" with no stretcher bars; they ship flat and are made for framing. Our standard canvases are 0.75" gallery-wrapped over wooden stretcher bars and hang without a frame. Shutterfly’s canvases are 1.5" deep over solid wood.

Can I pick up a canvas the same day?+

Shutterfly offers same-day CVS and Walgreens pickup for photo prints from 4×6 to 16×20. Sticker Supply Co offers free pickup of canvases at its South Portland, Maine shop once your order is ready; canvases typically ship in 3–4 business days.

Does Shutterfly sell yard signs too?+

Yes. Shutterfly sells 18" × 12" corrugated plastic yard signs, printed on both sides with an aluminum H-step stake included. Sticker Supply Co’s yard signs are 24" × 18", printed on both sides with a metal H-stake included, and a designer prepares the proof.

Research notes and sources

Competitor information was checked against the public pages below on November 11, 2026. Products, prices, policies, and turnaround can change, so confirm time-sensitive details before ordering.

Shutterfly is a trademark of its respective owner. Sticker Supply Co is not affiliated with or endorsed by Shutterfly. This page is an informational comparison based on publicly available information and our own service practices.

Still deciding? Send us the real job.

Tell us the surface, quantity, deadline, and what matters most. We will recommend the material and process we would use—before you commit.