A local BuildASign alternative

Sticker Supply Co vs BuildASign

BuildASign is an online sign printer headquartered in Austin, Texas and owned by Cimpress, known for fast yard signs and a wide choice of sign materials. Sticker Supply Co is a small print shop in South Portland, Maine where a designer prepares your yard sign proof, the stake comes with the sign, and you can pick the order up yourself.

Independently researched · Last reviewed November 11, 2026

The honest take

BuildASign is built for speed and choice in signs: yard signs typically ship the next business day, with aluminum and other premium materials, no minimums, and Saturday phone hours. Choose Sticker Supply Co for standard 24" × 18" yard signs printed on both sides with a stake included, a proof prepared by a designer, and free pickup in Greater Portland.

Feature by feature

How Sticker Supply Co and BuildASign compare

The right choice depends on the job. Here is the practical difference across the factors that usually matter most.

Who makes it

Depends on the job
Sticker Supply Co
A small print team in South Portland, Maine
BuildASign
Online sign printer headquartered in Austin, Texas, owned by Cimpress

Yard sign materials

Competitor edge
Sticker Supply Co
One size: 24" × 18" on 4mm corrugated plastic
BuildASign
Corrugated plastic plus premium materials such as aluminum

Printing and stakes

Sticker Supply edge
Sticker Supply Co
Always printed on both sides, with a metal H-stake included
BuildASign
Single- or double-sided; posts, frames, and stakes added separately

File check before printing

Sticker Supply edge
Sticker Supply Co
A designer prepares the proof and you approve it before printing
BuildASign
Advertises a free artwork check; its Terms of Sale say signs are not checked for content or spelling

Speed

Competitor edge
Sticker Supply Co
Plan your deadline directly with the team; rush orders available
BuildASign
Yard signs typically processed and shipped by the next business day

Getting your order

Sticker Supply edge
Sticker Supply Co
Free local pickup in South Portland, Maine, or shipping anywhere in the US
BuildASign
Shipped to you

Canvas prints

Depends on the job
Sticker Supply Co
Thin flat canvas or 0.75" gallery wrap, 8×10 to 18×24, optional wood frames and watercolor styling
BuildASign
0.75" standard wrap or 1.5" gallery wrap, floater frames on the 0.75" wrap

Support

Strong on both
Sticker Supply Co
Call or email the team making your order, weekdays 8:30–5 ET
BuildASign
Phone weekdays 7–7 and Saturdays 9–6 Central, plus chat

Guarantee

Competitor edge
Sticker Supply Co
Report defects or our mistakes within 7 days for a reprint or refund
BuildASign
100% satisfaction guarantee, and a 90-day warranty against manufacturing defects

Give credit where it is due

What BuildASign does well

A useful comparison should make the competitor's case too. These are meaningful strengths—not straw men.

  • Yard signs typically processed and shipped by the next business day
  • Premium sign materials such as aluminum, alongside corrugated plastic
  • No minimum quantities on yard signs, with volume discounts
  • Canvas in a 0.75" standard wrap or 1.5" gallery wrap, with floater frames

A designer prepares your proof

Upload your design and our team prepares the proof; nothing prints until you approve it. BuildASign advertises a free artwork check, but its Terms of Sale say signs are not checked for content or spelling.

Second side and stake included

Every 24" × 18" sign is printed on both sides of 4mm corrugated plastic and comes with a metal H-stake. BuildASign sells posts, frames, and stakes separately.

Pick up in South Portland

Choose free local pickup at checkout and collect your signs at our shop near the Maine Mall, or have them shipped anywhere in the US.

Signs, stickers, and labels from one shop

Order event or campaign signs alongside die-cut stickers, product labels, and decals from the same team, with the same proofing.

Match the printer to the project

Three questions that make the choice easier

1

Do you need signs shipped tomorrow, or metal signs?

BuildASign is the better fit; its yard signs typically ship the next business day and it offers aluminum and other premium materials.

2

Ordering standard yard signs in Maine?

Choose Sticker Supply Co. Our 24" × 18" signs are printed on both sides with a stake included, and you can pick them up free in South Portland.

3

Do you need stickers or labels too?

Sticker Supply Co prints custom stickers, labels, and decals as well, so one team can proof and produce the whole order.

South Portland, Maine

What every order gets from us

These are not premium support tiers. They are how our small team handles everyday work.

Designer-prepared proof before anything prints
Double-sided yard signs with the stake included
Free local pickup in South Portland, Maine
Direct access to a real person on our team
Internal quality checks before the order ships
Defects and our mistakes reprinted or refunded

Questions, answered

Sticker Supply Co vs BuildASign FAQ

Is Sticker Supply Co a good alternative to BuildASign for yard signs?+

Yes, for standard 24" × 18" yard signs, especially in Maine. Ours are printed on both sides of 4mm corrugated plastic, include a metal H-stake, get a designer-prepared proof, and can be picked up free in South Portland. For other sizes, metal signs, or next-day shipping, BuildASign has more options.

Are stakes included with BuildASign yard signs?+

BuildASign’s FAQ says posts, frames, and stakes are added to the cart separately and ship separately. Sticker Supply Co includes a metal H-stake with every yard sign.

Does BuildASign check my artwork?+

BuildASign’s homepage advertises a free artwork check, while its Terms of Sale say signs are not checked for content, spelling, or grammar. Sticker Supply Co has a designer prepare your proof, and nothing prints until you approve it.

Which is faster?+

BuildASign says yard signs are typically processed and shipped by the next business day. Sticker Supply Co works through a proof with you first; call us with your deadline and we will plan around it, including rush orders.

Research notes and sources

Competitor information was checked against the public pages below on November 11, 2026. Products, prices, policies, and turnaround can change, so confirm time-sensitive details before ordering.

BuildASign is a trademark of its respective owner. Sticker Supply Co is not affiliated with or endorsed by BuildASign. This page is an informational comparison based on publicly available information and our own service practices.

Still deciding? Send us the real job.

Tell us the surface, quantity, deadline, and what matters most. We will recommend the material and process we would use—before you commit.